I like having my lists have an even number of entries, but I can only include what I watched, so here are my favorite nine shows of 2007!
9. The Sopranos
“Historically, Carmine always said the Sopranos are nothing more than a glorified crew. Plain and simple—we decapitate and we do business with whatever’s left.”
Well. . .got that done. I was never a Sopranos addict, but I certainly understood why the show was as popular as it was. Here’s the thing about good stories – they should all have good endings. At the very least they should have an ending. The craptacular finale doesn’t completely negate all the good stuff that transpired in “Part II” of season 6, but it did leave a sour taste in most people’s mouths. Frankly, I think anyone who claims to like the “ending” of the finale is only trying to justify it in their minds because of all the time that they wasted expecting a culmination that never came. Because in the end, The Sopranos was just a fantastic journey that had no destination. The untied ends really shows nothing but contempt for the audience, which would be OK if it were a poorly made show. It wasn’t and the great buildup that occurred throughout the bulk of the season deserved a much better payoff.
Favorite Episode: 6.20 – The Blue Comet
8. Lost
“I’m going to lead my people up to the radio tower and I’m going to make a call. I’m going to get them rescued. Every one of them … And then I’m going to come find you, and I’m going to kill you.”
I came dangerously close to quitting on this show all together early on. If I hadn’t invested two whole seasons worth of time already I probably would not have pressed on after the miserably bad first half of season three. Thankfully, I did and Lost recovered to give us some of the best stuff they’ve made since season one. There’s still no protagonist on the air today that rubs me the wrong way more than Jack (say what you want, but this show is really good at making hateable characters), and in the back of my mind I keep thinking we’re headed towards an ultimate disappointment that will dwarf that of The Sopranos, but for the second half of this season at least I enjoyed the ride.
Favorite Episode: 3.22 – Through The Looking Glass
7. It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia
“’Peaked,’ Dee? Let me tell you something. I haven’t even begun to peak. And when I do peak, you’ll know. Because I’m going to peak so hard, that everybody in Philadelphia will feel it.”
I just started watching this show this year, which is surprising because the fact that this show centers around a group of guys that own an Irish pub in Philadelphia places me in the exact center of their target demographic. I didn’t care for the first season that much, but I’m glad I plowed on through because once Danny Devito joined this cast, things really took off. The show is a little hit or miss sometimes (OK, a lot), but I definitely detect shades of Arrested Development here – and that’s a hell of a compliment. Unfortunately, IASIP is way more uneven than AD ever was and sometimes those moment where they just seem to be trying too hard makes me miss the genius of Arrested Development even more. That being said, how do you not laugh at Danny Devito dropping acid at a tailgate during an Eagles tryout?
Favorite Episode: 3.14 – Bums: Making A Mess All Over The City
6. 24
“I’m feeling ambivalent. I’m gonna go.”
This is painful for me to do, and it’s strange not to see 24 in the top slot but I have to be honest here. I’ve already spoken at length on the problems 24 had this year and I take no joy in trashing my favorite show of all time so I’m going to focus on some of the positives that kept me tuning in every week despite the lowered quality of the product. Season six was well short of being a classic, but did feature some great 24 moments: Jack having to kill Curtis, the terrorists finally succeeding in detonating a nuke, the Graem torture scene, the return of the Logans, Fayed’s brutal death (“Damn, Jack!”), Tom Lennox’s awesomness in general, and the final silent scene finding Jack saying goodbye to Audrey facing an uncertain future. 24 is in new territory with it’s first “bad” season, but guess where I’ll be every Monday at 9 whenever it returns? Hopefully next year I’ll be back to laughing with, not at, the show in my random thoughts.
Favorite Episode: 6.17 – 10PM-11PM
5. Heroes
“Every hero must learn his purpose. Then he’ll be tested and called to greatness.”
And David takes out Goliath. Yes, I have newcomer Heroes ranked over 24. Although this show has plenty of problems of its own, it was just flat out more entertaining than 24 this year (so were a lot of shows, really). The basis of the show (if I may borrow an observation from Mike Nelson) is a completely un-X-Men-like premise of normal people suddenly discovering they have amazing powers. I wish the show was a bit more even (there are moments of astounding stupidity), it has more of a TV feel than the more cinematic production values of 24 or The Shield, and I want to punch Mohinder in the head, but this is one of those shows where you’ll want to watch the next episode immediately after you finish one.
Favorite Episode: 1.9 – Homecoming
4. Scrubs
“So what rhymes with baptism? Raptism? Schmaptism? Naptism? I’m so tired I could use a naptism…and there’s my opening joke! I should write ‘pause for laughter’ so I don’t forget!”
It’s taken me forever, but I’ve finally caught up with Scrubs in its entirety via DVD. It’s been great finally filling in the back story (I only started watching this show regularly a couple years ago), but it also is apparent to me that unfortunately, its best days are behind it. That being said, it’s still one of my favorite shows on the air. Season six was the pregnancy season where Dr. Cox, the Turks, and JD were all dealing with their new arrivals. In the meantime, Elliot becomes engaged to become Mrs. Keith Dudemeister and Sacred Heart loses a long time cast member when Laverne dies. This season also featured a classic musical episode. As previously stated, season six was not the best, however it was a step up from the previous couple of seasons.
Favorite Episode: 6.7: My Musical
3. South Park
“Mrs. Clinton, it appears that the terrorists have snuck a snuke up your snizz.”
I’m starting to think that this show will never lose it’s mojo. Season 11 finds Randy Marsh on Wheel of Fortune trying to solve “People who annoy you” with the board showing N_GGERS (the correct letter is ‘A’), Cartman “stumbling” into a compromising photo with Butters, Kyle having to kill Jesus to save Easter, and Mrs. Garrison discovering she/he is into chicks (and apparently the movie 300). The highlights of this season, however, was the 24 spoof, “The Snuke,” and the Imaginationland Trilogy where we finally see Al Gore’s worst nightmares regarding Manbearpig coming true. I think last season was more solid overall, but this was still a great year for Matt and Trey.
Favorite Episode: 11.4 – The Snuke
2. The Office
“Love that Andy right? Solid fellow. Seems smart enough, likes me a lot. A lot. Too much, like a crazy person, a little. Not super crazy, just…there’s something about him that creeps me out, I can’t really explain it. He’s always up in my bidness, which is Ebonics for “being in my face and annoying the bejesus out of me”. I don’t understand how someone can have so little self-awareness.“
How does anybody not love this show? The Office is now clearly the best comedy on television and season three was maybe the best yet. After Pam’s rejection, Jim leaves the Scranton branch until Scranton absorbs Jim’s new home branch. This leads to a whole slew of new cast members, with only Andy and Karen remaining in the end. Highlights of this season include Dwight hatching a coup against Michael, the celebration of Diwali, the gang making nog-a-sakes in “A Benihana Christmas” (which also shows Michael “marking” an asian girl with a Sharpie so he can tell her apart from her co-worker), Phyllis’ wedding, Michael speaking in Ryan’s class, and several employees compete for Jan’s job. The grand finale, of course, was Jim dumping Karen to finally, finally go on a date with Pam. What is amazing about this show in it’s third season is that it simply delivered week after week after week. I never recalled ever being disappointed and this show, along with Scrubs, made Thursday nights one of my favorite times of the week.
Favorite Episode: 3.10 – A Benihana Christmas
1. The Shield
Vic: You think I’m a cop killer. Maybe I am. You’re a cop, right?
Kavanaugh: That sounds like a direct threat on my life, Detective. You know what that means?
Vic: It means you just stepped onto an entirely new playing field. And for your sake, I hope you know the rules of the game.
Following the fall of 24 this year, it makes me appreciate all the more what The Shield is accomplishing in it’s sixth season. This show is still getting better! This year saw Vic Mackey consumed ever more by rage and vengeance to try and find the one who killed his team member Lem – only to finally realize that it was another member of his Strike Team. Meanwhile, the Kavanaugh investigation into Vic’s past sins reaches a dramatic conclusion and Claudette enacts a plan to purge the Barn of the Strike Team’s corruption once and for all now that she is finally in charge. In a parallel story, Shane is borderline suicidal as he tries to deal with his guilt over Lem’s death. Season six was oppressively dark as the walls closed in on our “heroes” paying the price for their past mistakes. It’s hard to impress someone who has seen all of Jack Bauer’s torture techniques, but seeing what Vic did to who he thought murdered Lem literally gave me chills. This season of The Shield was the best yet, and I can’t wait to see how this series concludes with the last season next year.
Favorite Episode: 6.3 – Back To One